N1

πŸ“– Japanese Grammar Guide N1: ~(γ‚ˆ)γ†γ¨γ€œγΎγ„γ¨ / (γ‚ˆ)γ†γŒγ€œγΎγ„γŒ

πŸ“Œ What is this grammar?

This is a hypothetical concessive structure used to express:

  • “Whether (someone) does or doesn’t do something, (the result won’t change)”
  • It presents two opposing possibilities (do or not do) and states that the result, situation, or decision remains unaffected.

πŸ“– Structure

TypeStructure
Verb (volitional form) + と / が + Verb (dictionary negative form without γͺい + まい) + と / がWhether (someone) does or doesn’t do…

βœ… まい is a classical negative volitional meaning β€œprobably won’t / let’s not / will not”.

Verb conjugation:

  • Group 1: 葌く β†’ θ‘Œγ“γ†γƒ»θ‘ŒγγΎγ„
  • Group 2: ι£ŸγΉγ‚‹ β†’ ι£ŸγΉγ‚ˆγ†γƒ»ι£ŸγΉγΎγ„
  • Irregular:
    • する β†’ γ—γ‚ˆγ†γƒ»γ™γ‚‹γΎγ„
    • ζ₯γ‚‹ β†’ ζ₯γ‚ˆγ†γƒ»ζ₯まい

🎨 Meaning in Context

Used when:

  • Emphasizing that no matter what choice is made (whether A or B), the conclusion/result is the same.
  • Often used in a formal, strong-willed, or logical context.

English equivalents:

  • “Whether (someone) does or doesn’t…”
  • “Regardless of whether (someone) does… or not”

πŸ“š Example Sentences

JapaneseEnglish
ι›¨γŒι™γ‚γ†γ¨ι™γ‚‹γΎγ„γ¨γ€θ©¦εˆγ―θ‘Œγ‚γ‚Œγ‚‹γ€‚Whether it rains or not, the game will be held.
彼がζ₯γ‚ˆγ†γŒζ₯γ‚‹γΎγ„γŒγ€η§γŸγ‘γ―ε§‹γ‚γ‚‹γ€‚Whether he comes or not, we’ll start.
ζˆεŠŸγ—γ‚ˆγ†γ¨γ—γΎγ„γ¨γ€ζŒ‘ζˆ¦γ™γ‚‹δΎ‘ε€€γŒγ‚γ‚‹γ€‚Whether it succeeds or not, it’s worth trying.
θͺ°γŒθ³›ζˆγ—γ‚ˆγ†γŒγ—γΎγ„γŒγ€η§γ―γ‚„γ‚‹γ¨ζ±Ίγ‚γŸγ€‚Whether anyone agrees or not, I’ve decided to do it.
ι£ŸγΉγ‚ˆγ†γ¨ι£ŸγΉγΎγ„γ¨γ€δ»£ι‡‘γ―εŒγ˜γ γ€‚Whether you eat or not, the price is the same.

πŸ“Œ Nuances & Tone

  • Very formal, logical, or resolute.
  • Often appears in speeches, essays, formal discussions.
  • Implies a strong stance, clear outcome, or logical certainty.

πŸ“ Comparison with Similar Patterns

ExpressionMeaningNuance
ο½žγ‚ˆγ†γ¨ο½žγΎγ„γ¨Whether (someone) does or doesn’tFormal, decisive
ο½žγ¦γ‚‚ο½žγͺくてもWhether or notMore casual
ο½žγ«γ‹γ‹γ‚γ‚‰γšRegardless ofNeutral
ο½žγ γ‚γ†γŒο½žγ γ‚γ†γŒWhether it’s A or BConversational

Example:

  • ι›¨γŒι™γ£γ¦γ‚‚ι™γ‚‰γͺγγ¦γ‚‚θ‘Œγγ€‚ β†’ I’ll go whether it rains or not. (casual)
  • ι›¨γŒι™γ‚γ†γ¨ι™γ‚‹γΎγ„γ¨θ‘Œγγ€‚ β†’ I’ll go whether it rains or not. (formal, resolute)

βœ… Practice Exercise

Translate into Japanese using ο½žγ‚ˆγ†γ¨ο½žγΎγ„γ¨ / ο½žγ‚ˆγ†γŒο½žγΎγ„γŒ:

  1. Whether you study or not, the exam will come.
  2. Whether he agrees or not, we’ll proceed.
  3. Whether it succeeds or fails, it’s worth trying.

Possible Answers:

  1. ε‹‰εΌ·γ—γ‚ˆγ†γ¨γ—γΎγ„γ¨γ€θ©¦ι¨“γ―ζ₯る。
  2. ε½ΌγŒθ³›ζˆγ—γ‚ˆγ†γŒγ™γ‚‹γΎγ„γŒγ€η§γŸγ‘γ―ι€²γ‚γ‚‹γ€‚
  3. ζˆεŠŸγ—γ‚ˆγ†γ¨ε€±ζ•—γ—γ‚ˆγ†γ¨γ€ζŒ‘ζˆ¦γ™γ‚‹δΎ‘ε€€γŒγ‚γ‚‹γ€‚

πŸ“ Summary Table

Grammarο½žγ‚ˆγ†γ¨ο½žγΎγ„γ¨ / ο½žγ‚ˆγ†γŒο½žγΎγ„γŒ
MeaningWhether (someone) does or doesn’t
Structure[Volitional form] + と / が + [Dictionary negative stem + まい] + と / が
NuanceStrong, formal, logical
UsageEssays, speeches, resolute declarations

πŸ“‘ Pro Tip:

This grammar pattern pairs really well with decisive verbs like:

  • θ‘Œγγ€ζ₯る、する
  • θ³›ζˆγ™γ‚‹γ€εε―Ύγ™γ‚‹γ€ζˆεŠŸγ™γ‚‹γ€ε€±ζ•—γ™γ‚‹
    β†’ As it naturally expresses decisiveness despite circumstances.
27 Views

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *